Simple Agreements for Future Equity (SAFEs, for short) have become a popular tool. They can help with raising capital for startups and this can impact M&A deals. SAFEs allow businesses to raise funds without immediately giving up equity. They can also push back the timeline for a formal valuation. For those navigating mergers and acquisitions, understanding this agreement is crucial. It presents unique benefits—and challenges—that can impact deal outcomes.
Defining SAFE Agreements—The Basics
A SAFE is a flexible financial contract between a company and an investor. Unlike traditional financing methods, it’s neither debt nor equity at the time of signing. Instead, it’s the right to future equity based on certain conditions. For example, an investor may contribute capital to a startup. Then in return, they receive the right to obtain shares when the company undergoes a certain event. This could include an acquisition or future equity funding round.
Originally developed by Y Combinator, SAFEs are a simpler, more founder-friendly alternative to convertible notes. Unlike convertible debt, there’s no maturity date or interest. But how does this translate into the real world, especially in M&A deals? Let’s break it down.
How Exactly Do SAFEs Work?
SAFE agreements are simple in their structure, and they come with lots of utility. Here’s how they often function:
- The Investor Contributes Capital: Rather than immediate equity, the investor receives an option for future ownership. Their funds can convert into equity under certain predefined conditions.
- Trigger Events for Conversion: These can include a future financing round, acquisition, or other liquidity events.
- Discounts and Valuation Caps: Some SAFE agreements come with a discount or valuation cap. This can help the investor get a favorable deal when their investment converts into equity.
Examples of SAFE Scenarios in M&A
In mergers and acquisitions, SAFEs can add a layer of complexity to the transaction. Here are a few scenarios where SAFEs come into play:
- Company Acquisition While SAFEs Are Still Active: If a startup with active SAFEs is acquired, the acquirer may need to negotiate how to handle the agreements. They could convert to equity, or maybe pay off investors another way. This could prevent ownership dilution.
- M&A Deal Post-Equity Conversion: If the SAFE converts into equity before an acquisition, it will simply factor into the current mix of shareholders., This can make negotiations more transparent.
Tax Treatment of SAFEs
One often-overlooked aspect of Simple Agreements for Future Equity (SAFE) is their tax treatment. SAFEs are not categorized as equity or debt. This creates unique tax implications for both the company and investors.
- Companies: The capital raised via SAFEs is not considered income. It’s commonly treated as a liability until converted into equity.
- Investors: No immediate tax events occur upon signing a SAFE, but tax obligations may arise when the SAFE converts to equity. This could trigger capital gains taxes.
SAFE Pros and Cons: What Businesses Should Know
Though SAFEs sound simple, they come with both advantages and risks. Businesses, especially those involved in M&A, should navigate carefully.
Pros
- Speed and Simplicity: No need for complicated equity negotiations or debt terms. Companies can issue SAFEs quickly. This can make them ideal for early-stage fundraising.
- Flexibility: There’s no fixed maturity date, and the SAFE can convert to equity under various conditions. This can provide more flexibility.
- Founder-Friendly: SAFEs don’t require immediate equity transfer or debt repayment. This helps companies retain control while securing capital.
Cons
- Uncertainty in Outcomes: Unlike traditional equity or debt, SAFEs leave more uncertainty about the final terms of conversion.
- Potential for Dilution: Depending on the terms, investors who hold SAFEs may end up with a big share of equity. This can have a big impact on M&A deals.
- Risk to Investors: Investors have no legal protections typical of debt instruments. If the company fails to raise more funding or misses other trigger events, it may lose its entire investment.
How SAFEs Factor Into M&A Deals
With mergers and acquisitions, SAFEs are becoming more relevant. For companies looking to raise early-stage funding, SAFEs present an easy way to bring in capital. However, their relevance goes beyond the speed of funding. M&A advisors should understand how SAFEs can impact the terms of a deal. For example:
- Effect on Company Valuations: Since SAFEs are not debt or equity, they can complicate a company’s overall valuation. Depending on the number of SAFE agreements, potential buyers need to assess the conversion agreements. How will they affect the equity pool and the post-transaction structure.
- Negotiating During Acquisitions: Buyers must decide whether to allow SAFEs to convert into equity or structure a different deal to pay off investors. This can add complications in deal negotiations, especially if the company’s valuation is still uncertain.
Understanding the impact of SAFEs in M&A is crucial. They can simplify early funding but can also complicate exit strategies. There are many ways to manage these agreements and deals.
Key Takeaways for SAFEs and M&A
Simple Agreements for Future Equity (SAFE) have become a favored tool in the startup world. They can help with raising capital upfront. However, their impact goes far beyond that initial round of funding. For businesses on the cusp of a merger or acquisition, SAFEs represent a unique financing tool. When using them wisely, owners can fuel growth without giving up immediate control. That said, they carry different pros and cons for both founders and investors.
Whether you’re a startup or an acquirer, it’s good to understand SAFE agreements. If you’re exploring an M&A deal, working with experienced M&A advisors can lead to a better outcome. There are many financing considerations you don’t want to overlook.. Here are some key takeaways:
- What are SAFEs? Simple Agreements for Future Equity allow companies to raise capital. This is in exchange for future equity conversion under specific conditions.
- The Relevance of SAFE in M&A: SAFEs can complicate deal-making. They’re a key consideration in many mergers and acquisitions.
- How Advisors Can Help Navigate M&A Deals: Acquinox Advisors can assist in understanding the role of SAFEs and how they affect company valuations and negotiations.
We hope that you’ve found this article valuable for learning about SAFEs. If you’re interested in reading more, please subscribe below to get alerted of new articles as we write them.
